Best Football Cards to Buy: Must-Have Rookie Picks & Tips

Diving into the world of football cards can be as thrilling as a last-minute touchdown. With the 2021 season having wrapped up, you’re probably wondering which cards are the MVPs of your collection.

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just getting your cleats dirty, knowing which 2021 football cards to snag is crucial. It’s not just about the players; it’s about the potential for these cards to skyrocket in value.

So, lace up and get ready to sprint through the top picks that’ll make your collection shine. You won’t want to miss out on the rookies and veterans that are turning heads in the football card game.

Top 2021 Football Card Picks

As you dive headfirst into the high-energy world of football card collecting, you’ll want to focus on a few standout players from the 2021 season. These athletes have made significant impacts on the field, and their cards are fast becoming hot commodities among collectors.

First up is Justin Herbert, the quarterback who’s been lighting up the scoreboard for the Los Angeles Chargers. His rookie cards are in high demand, and you’ll likely see their value continue to rise as his career progresses. With a strong arm and poise under pressure, Herbert’s cards are a must-have.

Next, keep an eye out for Joe Burrow cards. The Cincinnati Bengals QB has shown grit and talent despite a challenging season. Collectors are banking on his potential for greatness, making his cards a wise pick for anyone looking to invest.

Do not overlook the defensive side of the ball. Chase Young, with his dominant performances for the Washington Football Team, has become a top pick for defensive player cards. Young’s relentless pursuit of the quarterback makes his cards especially appealing to those who appreciate the art of defense.

For the wide receiver position, Justin Jefferson of the Minnesota Vikings has been nothing short of spectacular. Jefferson’s rookie cards should be on your radar due to his record-breaking season, which has put him in the conversation for one of the best wideouts in the game.

Here’s a quick list of other players whose 2021 cards you should consider adding to your collection:

  • Tua Tagovailoa, Miami Dolphins QB
  • CeeDee Lamb, Dallas Cowboys WR
  • Jonathan Taylor, Indianapolis Colts RB

Rookie Cards to Keep an Eye On

In your search for the best football card investments, there’s something thrilling about rookie cards. These pieces of memorabilia not only capture the moment a player steps into the limelight but also bear the potential for significant value increases as the athletes’ careers progress. Remember how your own journey started with promise and potential; these rookies are at a similar crossroads, and their cards are tickets to share in their future successes.

Jordan Love and Jalen Hurts are a couple of names you’ll want to remember. Love hasn’t had a spotlight performance yet, but given the unpredictable nature of football, it’s wise not to overlook him. Hurts, on the other hand, is already showing signs of being a dynamic force on the field. His dual-threat capabilities as a passer and runner make his rookie cards particularly intriguing.

  • Jordan Love, Green Bay Packers
  • Jalen Hurts, Philadelphia Eagles

Don’t miss out on Brandon Aiyuk from the San Francisco 49ers either. His ability to turn short passes into long gains makes him a highlight reel and a potential breakout star. Additionally, keep an eye on Antonio Gibson of the Washington Football Team. As he solidifies his role as the lead back, his stock may well rise.

  • Brandon Aiyuk, San Francisco 49ers
  • Antonio Gibson, Washington Football Team

As you’re scouting for these rookie cards, watch as much game footage as possible. Stats are vital, but they don’t always capture a player’s heart or resilience – qualities that matter immensely in football. That’s a lesson you’ve learned well from your playing days. Remember, it’s not just about raw talent. It’s about growth, adaptability, and the sheer will to succeed. These rookies represent that spirit, and their cards will resonate more deeply with those who recognize the deeper aspects of the game. Keep that coach’s eye sharp and your collection could benefit immensely.

Veteran Cards with Growing Value

While you’re scouting potential in rookie cards, don’t overlook the seasoned players who’ve proven their worth. Veteran cards hold a special allure because they celebrate the careers of those who’ve left a lasting imprint on the game. As you delve into the world of football card collecting, you’re not just investing in players—you’re investing in histories etched on the gridiron.

Keep an eye on Tom Brady. Yes, it might seem like a no-brainer, but his cards have seen continual growth over the years, and as he continues to defy Father Time, his cards could escalate further in value. Even if you’re a day late and a dollar short to the Brady game, there’s room for growth.

Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson are two other names to watch. Despite not being the newest kids on the block, their cards have a potential upside due to their consistently high level of play and the loyalty of their fanbase. Every touchdown and every inch gained on the field could mean incremental increases in their card’s value.

Remember, it’s not just the quarterbacks who are worth your attention. Players like Aaron Donald and Derrick Henry have shown that every position has its stars, and savvy collectors know that these players’ cards can grow in worth just as impressively.

Always stay updated with player performances and career milestones, as these can be precursors to a surge in card prices:

  • Breakthrough seasons
  • MVP awards
  • Championship victories
  • Induction into the Hall of Fame

One piece of advice? Look for cards from reliable brands that are known for their quality and collectibility. And don’t forget to consider the condition of the card. Even veterans need to be in tip-top shape to make the cut for your collection. Keep your eyes on the prize and your collection could soon reflect not only the stars of tomorrow but the legends of today.

Must-Have Quarterback Cards

As a football coach and enthusiast, you know the impact a stellar quarterback can have on the game. Your experience tells you that the right QB can elevate the whole team, and this fact is not lost on collectors either. Quarterback cards are often the most sought after when it comes to football card investments for a good reason.

Patrick Mahomes remains at the top of the list. With a Super Bowl win under his belt and consistently impressive stats, his cards are blue-chip investments. Keep an eye out for his rookie cards and limited edition prints—a surefire way to bolster your collection’s value.

Next in line, Lamar Jackson has shown his unique dual-threat capabilities as both a runner and a passer, bringing a new dynamic to the quarterback position. Jackson’s 2019 MVP season put him squarely in the sights of savvy collectors. His rookie cards, especially those with autographs or low serial numbers, are must-haves for 2021.

Don’t overlook Josh Allen of the Buffalo Bills. His growth over the past season has been nothing short of meteoric. With Allen’s cannon arm and improved accuracy, his stock is on the rise. Cards to search for include his rookie card from Panini Prizm and any rare parallels that you might come across—they’re worth the chase.

While rookie cards capture the potential for greatness, don’t neglect cards of veteran QBs like Drew Brees and Tom Brady. Despite Brees heading into retirement, his legacy cards will remain valuable. Brady’s move to the Buccaneers and subsequent Super Bowl win only further cement his status as a football legend. Their high-end cards from key seasons and milestone games are essential pieces of football history for any collector.

As you’re hunting for these gems, remember to always verify the authenticity and check for grading status. Cards in mint condition with a high grade from PSA or Beckett hold significant value and can be the cornerstone of your collection. Focus on options that resonate with your passion for the game, those moments on the field that made your heart race. These are the cards that not only perform well as investments but also capture the spirit of the sport you love.

Collectible Cards from Rising Stars

When you’re eyeing potential investments in the sports card arena, don’t overlook the up-and-comers, the young guns making a name for themselves on the gridiron. These players may not have the acclaim of a Mahomes or Brady just yet, but what they have is potential – and in the card collecting world, potential can equate to profitability.

Joe Burrow and Justin Herbert have been turning heads with their impressive performances, propelling them into the spotlight. Burrow’s resilience and leadership, alongside Herbert’s record-breaking rookie campaign, create a buzz that makes their cards particularly enticing. You’ll want to keep an eye on their performance as their careers progress, each game potentially hiking up the value of their collectible cards.

Think about the trajectory of a player’s career. Cards depicting moments when these rising stars first showed their spark can be particularly valuable. Consider cards from Chase Young and Tua Tagovailoa. Young, with his Defensive Rookie of the Year award, and Tua, with his high draft pick status and flashes of brilliance, are prime examples. As they carve out their place in NFL history, their early cards are where you might hit gold.

Here’s a quick tip: watch the games, read the stats, but also listen to the buzz around these players. It’s not just about raw talent; it’s about market sentiment. If there’s chatter about a sophomore breakout season or comeback from injury, that’s when the smart money starts to pay attention.

Remember, the key to picking the right cards of rising stars lies in your understanding of football, your intuition, and your willingness to take a chance on players who exhibit exceptional talent and character. It’s not unlike scouting fresh talent for your dream team. Keep a sharp eye on player performances, injury reports, and potential trades. These factors can all act as indicators of a card’s future value.

Quarterback Yards Touchdowns Interceptions
Joe Burrow 4,611 34 14
Justin Herbert 4,336 31


You’ve got the scoop on the hottest football cards to snag for 2021. Remember, it’s all about timing and knowledge. Keep an eye on those rising stars and don’t miss out on cards that capture their breakout moments. Stay sharp, stay informed, and your collection could be the envy of fans and investors alike. Happy collecting!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can collecting football player cards be profitable?

Yes, investing in collectible cards of rising football stars can be profitable, especially if the players, like Joe Burrow or Justin Herbert, continue to perform well and generate buzz, thereby increasing their card values.

Who are some up-and-coming football players to consider for card collecting?

Joe Burrow and Justin Herbert are mentioned as examples of players whose cards are becoming more valuable. Collecting cards depicting significant moments of promising players like Chase Young and Tua Tagovailoa is also recommended.

How does an athlete’s performance affect the value of their collectible cards?

An athlete’s performance directly affects their card value. Outstanding play, record-setting games, and awards can significantly increase the demand and value of a player’s collectible cards.

What factors should collectors consider apart from individual performances?

Collectors should monitor player performances, injury reports, and potential trades, as these can all influence the future value of a player’s collectible cards.

Is it important to focus on specific moments when collecting football cards?

Yes, focusing on cards that capture significant moments in players’ careers, such as when they first show their potential, can be particularly valuable for collectors.

Scroll to Top